Blackmore
Assessment
17
June 1725
Dublin
A young girl whom we shall
call Laura for the purposes of this entry,
was brought to us today by her father who could no longer care for her in her
current state. The father informed us that his daughter had been making the
claim that she was being visited by
creatures in the night who wished to take her blood. Although he knows these
claims to be from her imaginings, Laura’s father, out of patrimonial duty,
stayed awake most nights to watch over her. The father was also compelled to
spend his days giving personal care to the young lady as she had become unable
to move from her bed due to a profound melancholy that had taken hold. The
father, thinking only of the well-being of Laura, left her in our care with the
promise of returning to retrieve her once he is
able to obtain a steady means of income.
As is customary for anyone being admitted to the House, Laura was required
to be seen by our house physician to ascertain her fitness for labor. The House
physician is a young man who fancies himself a progressive thinker in matters
of medical science. He is also very interested in matters of the human spirit
and recently attended a lecture by the eminent Dr. Richard Blackmore who had
recently published his Treatise of the
Spleen and Vapours. Our young doctor was eager to put his newfound
knowledge into use for the benefit of the residents of the house.
The physician of the house began by
assessing young Laura’s physical condition, noting the paleness of her skin and
pronounced weakness in her limbs. She also presented as being quite lethargic
in her movements, only moving when told to do so and even then with little
energy. The doctor also inspected Laura’s abdomen particularly her spleen and
noted that it indeed was enlarged and firmer than a spleen should be. Based on
this physical assessment and the symptoms reported by the young woman’s father,
our doctor determined that Laura was suffering from a clear case of what Dr.
Blackmore described as Hypochondriacal Affectation. The doctor explained that
this was a disorder caused by a malfunction of the spleen that causes noxious
vapours to be produced which are then inhaled which have a negative effect
upon Laura’s spirit.
Dr. Blackmores treatise laid forth a
treatment to alleviate the affliction of Hypochondriacal Affectations. First,
Laura will be started on a regimen of purging to dispel with the bilious fluids
that are contaminating her organs. The purging will be accomplished by a draught of Tinctura Sacta mixed with Spirit of
Lavender that Laura will drink every night before
going to bed. Once the purging has had time to
take effect, a medication comprised of Coral, Crab’s Eyes and Pearl mixed with
wine to be given three times a day to invigorate and strengthen the nerves.
If, after a time, these medicines do not
have an effect stronger medication may be required in combination with the
letting of blood. The kind doctor has requested that he monitor her progress
personally. Although this is out of the ordinary, I see no reason to deny this request.
C.L.
Battie
Assessment
17
June 1758
Dublin
Recently, I was called on by a
gentleman who was seeking help for his daughter who he feared was had given in
to madness. The young woman had apparently begun suffering delusions, believing
she was being visited by spirits in the night who were taking her blood. Soon
after the start of the delusions she fell into a severe melancholy often
staying in bed throughout the day. Having an interest in afflictions of the
mind and spirit I agreed to call upon the gentlemen and his daughter.
The gentleman was at the door
awaiting my arrival and quickly ushered me in to see his daughter. He gave her
name as Laura, who was quite a beautiful young lady despite the pallid color of
her skin and sunkenness of her cheeks. She hardly moved except to blink and
seemed to be staring off into the distance paying no attention to my presence
as I performed a physical assessment. Other than the previous described
description of the paleness of her skin and a slowed heart rate I could find no
evidence of injury or illness. I asked the father if she had been ill or
injured at any time prior to her current condition. The man told me she had
never been injured and that his daughter had always been quite healthy.
Having recently read Dr. William
Battie’s Treatise on Madness, I
ascertained that young Laura suffered from what Dr. Battie referred to as
original madness. This was an ailment that was not caused by anything external
but something that she was born with and that had gradually grown until it
presented itself in the symptoms we were seeing before us. Unfortunately, there
is no current remedy for this type madness and anything I did would merely be a
pretense. I explained this to Laura’s father who looked defeated by the
information. I explained that if she had suffered a fever or some form of
injury then it might be possible to perform treatments that would alleviate
pressure that may have built around her nerves or in her skull. That if her
madness had been consequential from a fever then a regimen of purging fluids from
her body through vomiting and bloodletting could ease pressure that would have
built up in the fluids surrounding her nerves which would remove the madness.
But that currently there was no known treatment for Laura’s condition and any
attempting a remedy would most likely cause more harm.
Before leaving I recommended to the
man that he have Laura placed in the care of Swifts Lunatic Asylum. They would
be able to provide care for her night and day and as new treatments arose she
would be available for him. He thanked me for my time and I promised to look in
on her and monitor her progress.
C.L
I love how you wrote this as an observation to a case in the separate perspectives of the time periods.
ReplyDeleteFor Blackmore…Do you think Blackmore actually found her spleen to be enlarged or wanted her spleen to be enlarged to corroborate his book? What are the chances that a man brings in his daughter with exactly what his book was written about! It makes me think it has more to do with the latter on that question. Were doctors being bias a concern at all in that time period? Did they have to have their books looked at by other doctors before being published or did they have to put it was a working theory that they had? Why would it be out of the ordinary for Blackmore to look in on Laura personally?
For Battie…he concluded that she had original madness that she was born with. Is this because she is a woman and was considered the weaker sex or was original madness for both sexes? Was original madness a general term used for people that had a mental instability with no physical premise to them?
On your Blackmore comments; I think we can easily see a confirmation bias with the doctor's assessment of Laura. He had just read Blackmore's writing and seen a lecture and was excited to put those theories into practice. So for the purposes of this writing without a doubt the doctor found what he wanted to find. As for peer review, at the time of these writings it would have been used more as an editorial tool prior to publication and not for authenticity. Although, scientists would often debate their ideas in scientific society meetings (such as the Royal Society of London). They would also use their published writings to refute or support others ideas. As for the Doctor looking in on Laura personally, I'm not really sure if this would be out of the ordinary. I took some literary license to illustrate his enthusiasm for the case.
ReplyDeleteAccording to Battie, original madness was merely any type that had no obvious physical cause such as a head injury or prior illness that could explain the symptoms being observed. So, original madness is used in reference to both male and female.